Teaching synthetic phonics and reading: PIRLS of wisdom?
By Blog Editor, IOE Digital, on 10 October 2023
By Dominic Wyse on 10 October 2023
This is the first of three blog posts about the teaching of phonics, reading and writing. The approach of this blog series is characterised as ‘A Balancing Act’:
- Understanding the PIRLS 2021 results;
- England’s narrow approach to phonics teaching;
- What works for phonics, reading and writing.
The Balancing Act: Part 1
In an article in the Telegraph newspaper in May 2023 the Minister of State for Schools, Nick Gibb MP, claimed “Our ‘obsession’ with phonics has worked”. The claim was based on his interpretation of the Progress in International Reading and Literacy (PIRLS) 2021 study published earlier this year. The minister’s main point was that “England was fourth out of 43 comparable countries” because apparently teachers had “embraced phonics”. England’s average scale score in PIRLS 2021 was 558, compared to a score of 559 in the previous round, in 2016.