X Close

Anthropology of Smartphones and Smart Ageing Blog


Anthropology of Smartphones and Smart Ageing


Archive for the 'China' Category

‘Eating for the eyes’ in the age of smartphones

Xin Yuan Wang1 September 2020

Last month (August 2020), Chinese video platforms such as ‘douyin’ (TikTok) started banning videos of wanghong (internet influencers) who are known as ‘big stomach kings’ filming and broadcast themselves eating huge amounts of food in one go[1]. The crackdown is a reaction to the call from the Chinese leadership to reduce food waste, as food security had become an issue during the COVID-19 pandemic, as well as weeks of mass flooding across southern China[2]. The popular eating shows have been criticised as not only promoting a very unhealthy diet but also causing food waste, as many broadcasters faked the eating process by secretly throwing up in order to consume more on camera (fig.1).

Fig.1 Screenshots of a video on ‘douyin’ criticising fake eating shows, the majority of the eating videos from China’s ‘big stomach kings’ have disappeared from various video-sharing and live streaming platforms.

During my fieldwork, it was common to see such videos circulated among older people along with many other visual content where wanghong (internet influencers) play a significant role. Wanghong, which literally means ‘internet red’, was originally the Chinese term for internet influencers. Now, Wanghong can refer to anything that gains popularity and fame on social media. Among them, Wanghong food is one of the most common topics. On 65-year-old Caiyuan’s WeChat profile, we can find hundreds of photos of food, for example. One post (fig. 2) reads: “dinner on the Mother’s Day, a wanghong restaurant daka (checked).” The other one (fig. 3) reads “daka at a wanghong bubble milk tea shop, who can read the name of the shop?”

Fig. 2 Screenshot of Caiyuan’s WeChat post of her having dinner in a popular restaurant

Fig. 3 Screenshot of Caiyuan’s WeChat post showing her having bubble milk tea

Daka’, the verb people always apply in posts, along with wanghong, comes from the popular action of marking one’s physical location on social media. Previously, placed people commonly marked were famous places one would encounter when sightseeing or even the airport. More recently, wanghong restaurants and shops appear more and more often on people’s social media profiles.

On a WeChat group called ‘Good taste in Shanghai’, which has 292 members and was set up by a retired civil servant, daka wanghong restaurants have become the routine: in addition to home-made dishes, members share endless photos of wanghong food and restaurants (fig. 4). It is also not unusual to see people posting a link of a wanghong restaurant and saying: “I want to ‘daka’ this one next month, anybody in the group want to come along?”

Fig. 4 Screenshots of the ‘Good taste in Shanghai’ WeChat group

To put things in perspective, with or without wanghong, food has always been the centre of Chinese culture and social life. There is something else that should be known about the popularity of wanghong food and restaurants on people’s social media profiles. ‘Xiaofei shengji’, a term that translates to ‘an upgrade in consumption’ is something that characterises today’s rapidly growing Chinese middle class. Urban Chinese people in Shanghai, young and old alike, are keen to live a premium lifestyle, one that might include activities such as sophisticated dining. Given that people carry their ‘perpetually opportunistic’ [3] smartphone with them at all times, this means they are always ready to visually capture various daily experiences, sharing such visual evidence with more social contacts. In this context, many places and products gain fame online mainly because their outstanding appearance. The term ‘gao yanzhi’ (high level of good-looking) is widely used in the marketing of wanghong. Unlike ‘conspicuous consumption’ of luxury goods, which is not always available to ordinary people, the consumption of ‘light luxury’ (qing she meaning ‘affordable luxury’), has become one of the most popular events documented on social media. ‘Light luxury’ can be a cup of wanghong bubble milk tea, which may be double the price of similar products (and for which people might need to queue for two or three hours) or a meal in a wanghong restaurant that one needs to book a couple of weeks in advance.

Visual content plays a significant role in interpersonal communication as well as self-representation. In fieldwork, I found that it is common that people’s consumption was inspired by their friends’ posts of wanghong on social media. On top of this to post photos of wanghong is also the main reason to go to wanghong.

Once, another research participant, Luwei (50 years old) was having a coffee with me in a wanghong café. When the cheesecake arrived, she found she had left her smartphone at home. “It is almost as if the cheesecake was eaten in vain if I couldn’t take photos”, Luwei sighed. As she suggests, having nice food is not just about consuming it but also about producing ‘social media-worthy’ photos.

During my fieldwork, I witnessed the booming of the wanghong economy, the new digital business model that converts social media fans and followers into purchases. In 2018, the total number of wanghong fans in China was 588 million, with revenues centred around the  ‘wanghong economy’ exceeding $283 billion[4], almost 32 times as much as the country’s box office revenue ($8.9 billion) that year. Indeed, as a popular saying goes: ‘The good-looking is the number one productive force’ (yanzhi shi di yi shengchanli).

The wanghong economy, with its extreme focus on the ‘good-looking’ is, on the one hand, fuelled by the proliferation of the smartphone and social media. It also reinforces the significance of the visual content on people’s social media profiles. The ‘good-looking’ element has always being an important part of fine cuisine, as ‘people eat with their eyes’. From the big stomach kings’ wanghong videos to the ubiquitous photos of wanghong food, it is probably fair to say that in the age of smartphones, not only do people eat with their eyes but also for the eyes.

[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-food-wastage/china-cracks-down-on-big-stomach-kings-in-fight-against-food-wastage-idUSKCN259140 

[2] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-53761295

[3] Miller et al. (forthcoming) The Global Smartphone: beyond youth culture. London: UCL Press.

[4] http://www.bjreview.com/Nation/201908/t20190826_800176806.html

Grand-parenting in Post-COVID Shanghai 

Xin Yuan Wang5 June 2020

“It is like immediately after a bad drought you are now suffering from a flood!”, Yajing remarked half-jokingly, talking about grandmothering a five-year-old.

A few months ago, when mainland China was in deep trouble because of the pandemic, Yajing, like many grandparents nowadays in Europe, couldn’t see her granddaughter Xiaobao. During the lockdown, Yajing regularly posted photos of Xiaobao on her WeChat with lines such as “I wish the pandemic will pass soon so that I could hug Xiaobao again.”

Yajing’s wish did come true – since March, from entertainment to the workplace, many aspects of daily life have been returning to relative normality in mainland China[1]. Xiaobao’s parents went back to work in late March and the job of taking care of Xiaobao came to Yajing “naturally”, as she put it. After two months of total separation, Yajing is now spending every single second taking care of Xiaobao: a drought immediately followed by a flood.

Before COVID-19, Yajing had already taken major responsibility for Xiaobao: in the morning, Yajing picks Xiaobao from her daughter’s home and sends her to nursery. In the afternoon, she picks Xiaobao up from nursery, prepares dinner and reads books with her until 8 pm, when Xiaobao’s parents come to pick up her after work.

“Every day, I desperately look forward to the time when the nursery will open again. I love Xiaobao but the full-time duty of looking after her is just so exhausting. I keep no time to myself at all”, Yajing complained.

Because she has been taking care of Xiaobao, Yajing has had to turn down many social events with her friends and has also cancelled her planned holidays. What is worse is that she started to have difficulties falling asleep because of the stress.

Another research participant, Mr Guo (69), also expressed his bitterness: “Our older people are ‘kidnapped’ by the role of grandparents!”. Mr Guo’s remark may sound radical but it is not totally exaggerated. During my ethnography in Shanghai, I witnessed the common practice of older people taking an active, if not major, role in raising their grandchildren in order to help their children pursue professional goals. The moral judgement of being a good grandparent via the intensive care labour of grandchildren is widely held. Such a social expectation is so strong that older people may even feel forced, or ‘kidnapped’, as Mr Guo put it.

In Shanghai, Yajing and Mr Guo represent the majority of older people who have grandchildren. The phenomenon can be seen nationwide. In 2017, a Shanghai Urban Neighborhood Survey[2] conducted among 5100 households showed that 73.4% of preschool children are looked after by at least one grandparent and 31.7% of young couples do not get involved with the raising of preschool children. Another 2017 survey on the grandparents’ participation in family education in urban China[3] shows that almost 80% of Chinese households see grandparents taking an active role in raising children. Among families with preschool children, the percentage is 77.7%, among those with nursery-aged children it is 72.9%, and among families with primary school children, the percentage is 60.1%. In rural areas, the figure of is higher than 90%.

Yajing expressed her concern with regards to the reopening of the nurseries: “I am afraid the nurseries will be the last to reopen among all the schools, they know that our older people will take care of the kids anyway.” It is curious to see that in many European countries, governments considered reopening the nurseries at a very early stage. It is because many adults can only go back to work when their young children are being taken care of by the nurseries. Such a sharp comparison also throws light on the significant role the grandparents play in the social support system in China.

Figure: taking grandchildren to school and picking them up from school is one of the daily duties of grandparents in Shanghai. Photo taken by Xinyuan Wang.

From the family plan policy to the intergenerational gap, from the traditional filial piety to the devotion to the next generation – there is a lot to look into the issue of grandparenting, which is further highlighted in post-COVID China. For now, let’s just hope the nurseries reopen soon and Yajing can take a breath after the ‘flood’.

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesasquith/2020/03/19/a-positive-coronavirus-update-life-in-china-returning-to-normal-as-flights-to-london-resume/#584c67661f24

[2] https://www.thepaper.cn/newsDetail_forward_1986089

[3] https://www.jiemodui.com/N/100970.html