The Potential of Citizen Groups in Ulaanbaatar
By uczipm0, on 28 February 2019
This blog was written based on an academic article to be published by T. Bayartsetseg and Dr. Margot Rawsthorne in 2019. Bayartsetseg is a doctoral student at the Department of Social Work and Social Pedagogy, Ghent University, Belgium; lectures in social work at the National University of Mongolia; and is a paired researcher with Dr. Rebekah Plueckhahn on the Emerging Subjects team. Dr. Margot Rawsthorne is an Associate Professor and lectures on community development at the University of Sydney, Australia.
A couple of years ago, a story of a teenager who has been cleaning the Selbe river bank voluntarily after his class hours was circulated on mass media. The story was widely spread from TV interviews to the Mongolian Ministry of Environment and Tourism as an exemplary civic contribution to environmental well-being. Driven by a personal aspiration to create a recreational spot in a one of the ger districts, another man turned the dumpsite in the ger district of Chingeltei into an artificial pool where children can steer small boats for a small fee. More similar homegrown, communitarian examples are emerging particularly as Ulaanbaatar is becoming a more divided city with contestations over land. Today the growth of ger settlements surrounding the capital Ulaanbaatar is a striking illustration of social and spatial polarization similarly found throughout East and South East Asia . With increasing urban poverty (up to 40% of the population in ger district areas) and other pressing issues such as air pollution and health threats, the Mongolian national government has been narrowly focused on these issues with less attention being paid to the potentials of citizen driven initiatives . Whilst it is must to focus on these pressing concerns, a more localized, nuanced political perspective provides much more hope. What is at stake for the ger district residents is their ‘right to the city’—a demand for political, social and economic recognition . In addition, in the case of research conducted by the authors, more participatory habits and autonomy among the public is critically needed for more effective democracy. These demands appear to be rising through citizen groups and citizen actions in ger areas.
Citizen groups in the ger districts
People know more about financial saving groups in disadvantaged communities in Mongolia even though it is only one stream of citizen group activities in our country. ‘Citizen groups’ exist either as non-governmental organizations (NGO) or as cooperatives because their status is not yet legally determined. But it is definitely emerging as a form of civil society organization (irgenii niigem or ‘civil society group’ as we may call it in the future) in both rural and urban Mongolia. Citizen groups are less formal—similar to community-based organizations found in some other countries—and are marked through the possibility of receiving small grants through the Mongolian government’s Local Development Fund based at the respective sub-district administrative unit (or horoo in Mongolian). It is also common that they receive small-scale funds from international organizations for micro-scale environmental and infrastructural actions. In rare cases, they raise funds from its members as monthly donations. Membership is open for everyone in the neighborhood, but women dominate the membership overall by up to 80 percent. Forums, networks, councils and coalitions have started emerging in the civil society spheres of Mongolia for more ethical, collective and collaborative responses to social issues . The development of self-help groups, community development associations and other groups specifically for demographic variations such as women’s, children’s and elderly groups have been emergent in several other countries within Africa and Asia . Taylor and Mackenzie (1992), for example, highlighted that citizen group activities and micro management of community resources (particularly through various income-generation activities and savings groups) brought better results in comparison to any other anti-poverty interventions implemented by the governments of Tanzania and Kenya .
From a critical perspective, more research-founded elucidation is needed in order to reveal the multiple functions, classifications and possible contributions of civil society organizations to contemporary Mongolian society. Bumochir Dulam has noted that Mongolia lacks consistency in understanding the content and application of the term ‘civil society’ despite the fact of this term being widely used in social and political discourse not only in Mongolia but also in many other countries worldwide . This is also the case with citizen groups as its members are challenged and asked by public executive bureaus what they mean by ‘citizen group’ when they approach bureaus for support and collaboration. In other cases, they can be a target of suspicion as a group of constituents representing a politician or a political party. The law on NGOs in Mongolia, approved in 1997, does not specify community-based organization or citizen groups in its provisions. In addition, there are fewer local NGOs that support community initiatives compared to those that work in more mainstream areas such as child protection, gender issues and violence against women. In many cases, the idea was initially introduced by international donor organizations such as UN Habitat in Mongolia, however, there are many local ideas and initiatives that are growing as part of greater aspirations to bring about change in peoples’ living environments. However, regardless of the concept’s origin, citizen groups are becoming an undeniable part of emerging civil society in addition to more formal NGOs and cooperatives to support the community from grassroots level.
In this timely moment of discussion to amend the law on NGOs in Mongolia, citizen groups are a form of social organization that needs to be considered, so that they can further develop legally, financially and structurally as a valid form of civic engagement in development. As a survival strategy, most capable citizen groups try to register themselves as NGOs as it allows them to participate more in community initiatives and contribute to development on a micro-scale. Funding remains to be an influential factor for sustainability of these citizen groups as there are many cases of groups dying down after the initial excitement of donor organization funding, or from the local horoo, has stopped. Behind the curtains of citizen group funding, the clandestine interests of parliament members, horoo officials and donor organizations compete to appropriate the name of the civil society group as a symbol of their democratic efficiency. In other words, citizen groups lack ownership (in addition to funding) over what they have achieved and what they are capable of. In general, as their status is unclear, discretions involving funding and the veiled interests of horoo level bureaucrats create challenges for citizen groups but also engender politics that can divide people in and between such groups.
From a productivity perspective, the capacity of citizen groups is not only limited to micro infrastructural works because they can also play an important role in planning entire neighborhoods. One of the citizen groups in Songinokhairkhan district, for instance, drafted a comprehensive horoo development plan without the involvement of professional urban planners, which reflected their visions for small gardens, green areas, schools and kindergartens and even the location of their water well. The district mayor’s office endorsed the plan at that time, but, as is common in Mongolia, the effectiveness of the plan was reduced to a piece of paper when the local government structure changed with newly elected members. Another threat to such citizen driven initiatives is the politics surrounding local tender bidding for micro infrastructure development works. In some cases, tender offers from citizen groups were overridden by business entities although citizen group proposed the most cost-effective financial bid.
Developing citizen groups beyond the ‘problem-oriented’ approach
As mentioned above, ger districts in Ulaanbaatar have been predominantly framed within a ‘problem’ discourse, limiting its usefulness and generative scope for citizen participation. In other words, academic research has emphasized the fact that we tend to portray ger districts as a deficit area settled by in-country migrants with an increased necessity to develop infrastructure, to minimize health risks and to reduce the prevalence of crime and school dropouts . When boxed into a ‘problem’ discourse, it is common that people resignedly accept the current infrastructurally-poor living conditions and remain passive in community initiatives. Some may withdraw from organized activities aimed towards community improvement, presuming that they cannot do anything to eradicate problems faced in the district in any way. In other words, individuals start developing ignorance and using defense and denial as a means of coping . Ultimately, it becomes more difficult to recognize or foster organic or homegrown initiatives that emerge from local areas and easier to follow international practice suggestions.
Returning again to the case of the aforementioned teenage boy and the entrepreneurial man in Chingeltei district, further cases such as these can spread when residents in disadvantaged ger areas share more common aspirations and collaborate with their horoos more closely. Many Mongolians currently desire a greater sense of political agency that can effect change from a personal to a collective level. This may sound idealistic, but we need a communitarian mindset to help promote such micro movements. When Mr. Bat-Uul was Ulaanbaatar’s City Mayor, the Mayor’s Office established around 10 working bureaus to cooperate with residents in peripheral ger areas (захирагчийн ажлын алба). Unfortunately, lacking ways and means to collaborate with its residents, the functions of those bureaus were unclear and staff motivation was low. This is because local civil initiatives in Mongolia are being hindered by the heavy focus on program implementation and management of welfare payments, as well as lack strategies to work with people and informal groups like citizen groups.
Referring back to Lefebvre’s idea of the ‘right to the city’, the city has its own life, secrets and powers. In Ulaanbaatar, there is also a large amount of resourcefulness. We may need a paradigm shift from the dominant focus on planned physical structure to more flexible, inclusive and lively methods of mediating between different types of knowledge and strategies. In this effort, citizen groups are one of the social forces that play a pivotal role in invigorating ger areas’ liveliness and dynamics. The growth of citizen groups could be a way to trigger further citizen participation and community development in Mongolia in this moment of heated talk about civic engagement in development. Understanding what citizen groups are and how they function still needs further research. However, based on several successful cases, citizen groups can do more ground-up works to compensate ineffectiveness of government interventions particularly in peripheral ger areas if recognized properly. Linking citizen-driven initiatives to macro-level policy environment is vital if the government is to genuinely support citizen engagement in development. Indeed, the Government of Mongolia would benefit from cooperating with citizen-driven initiatives, where they can learn from their ‘insider’ experience as an essential step in curbing those critical issues.
 Fung, K., Craig, C (2017). One concept many practices: Diverse understandings of community development in East and South East Asia. Community Development Journal. 52, 1-9.
 Report by the Mongolian National Broadcaster, October, 2018. Accessed via http://www.mnb.mn/j/204
 Butler, C. (2012). The right to the city. In Butler, C (Ed), Henri Lefevbre Spacial Politics, Everyday Life and the Right to the City. Routlege, NY: USA, pp.143-159.
 Undarya, T (2013). State of civil society development in Mongolia. Mongolian journal of international affairs, 18, 58-63
 Chen, Yi, Wen, Ku.Y. (2016). Community practice at a crossroad: the approaches and challenges in Taiwan. Community Development Journal. 52 (1), 76-91.
 Taylor, D. R. F, Makcenzie, F (1992). Development from within. Routlege, London: United Kingdom
 Bum-Ochir, D (2018). Mongolia. In Ogawa A (Ed). Routledge Handbook of Civil Society in Asia, Routlege, NY: USA, pp.95-109.
 Kamata T, Reichert, J, Tsevermig, T, Kin, Y, Sedgewick, B. (2010). Managing Urban Expansion in Mongolia. The International Bank for Reconstruction and the World Bank, Washington DC: USA.
 Lkhamsuren Kh, Choijiljav Ts, Budbazar E, Vanchinkhuu S., Blanc DC, Grundy J (2012) Taking action on the social determinants of health: Improving health access for the urban poor in Mongolia. Journal for Equity in Health. 11(15), 1-15.
 Theunissen, T (2014) Poverty, Inequality and the negative effects of Mongolia’s economic downturn. The Asia Foundation. Retrieved from http://asiafoundation.org/2014/06/25/poverty-inequality-and-the-negative-effects-of-mongolias-economic-downturn/. Accessed 27 August 2017.
 Kusago T, Hirata, Sh. (2016). The evolutionary path of the 21st Hyogo Long-term Vision Project in Japan: community development, resilience, and well-being. Community Development Journal, 52 (1), 160-170.
 Bayarsaikhan, A (2017). Where do you dwell? Neighborhood as a determinant of school attendance in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia. Journal of Education and Social Policy. 4 (4): 32-41.
 Leipold B, Greve, W. (2009) Resilience: A conceptual bridge between coping and development. European Psychologist, 14 (1): 40-50.
97 Responses to “The Potential of Citizen Groups in Ulaanbaatar”
Bigo88 wrote on 14 May 2023:
Segera daftar Di situs Slot Online sekarang di situs Bigo88 untuk mendapatkan user ID pro dan dijamin gacor.Hanya dengan memainkan satu user ID saja Anda sudah bisa mendapatkan banyak keuntungan dan profit yang besar.
manojey2 wrote on 14 May 2023:
WinRAR crack is a powerful archive manager software for Windows, Mac, Linux operating system. mazterize.cc This software is a powerful compression tool with many integrated …
totositerank.com wrote on 15 May 2023:
This content is simply exciting and creative. 토토사이트
sportstotoking.com wrote on 15 May 2023:
Thanks for every other great article. 먹튀검증
betsarang.com wrote on 15 May 2023:
The article you shared, it was very interesting and meaningful, 먹튀검증
totorank.net wrote on 15 May 2023:
There is certainly a great deal to learn about this subject.
igoal คาสิโน wrote on 15 May 2023:
Thanks for your awesome topic. I got very valuable information here!
HDFC DSA Registration wrote on 15 May 2023:
HDFC DSA Registration is a simple and secure process that allows you to become a part of the HDFC Bank’s Direct Selling Agent (DSA) network. It provides you with the opportunity to earn commissions by selling financial products like loans, credit cards and insurance policies. By registering as an HDFC DSA, you can access exclusive benefits such as training sessions, sales support, and rewards for achieving sales targets. With HDFC DSA Registration, you can become an official representative of the bank and take advantage of the numerous opportunities available in the banking sector.
MyKohlsCharge wrote on 16 May 2023:
Thanks for every other great article. MyKohlsCharge.com Payment
Williams2356 wrote on 17 May 2023:
It is recommended that you check your information Ally Bank for the most accurate information regarding payments.
CLICK HERE = ally financial payoff address
braveboy4598 wrote on 17 May 2023:
Domain administrators can access the recovery password via AD DS and use it to unlock the drive. Saving recovery passwords to AD DS is advised to make it possible for IT professionals to get the recovery passwords of drives inside their company in the event of need.
CLICK HERE = Aka.ms/recoverykeyfaq
Alice wrote on 17 May 2023:
Thank you so much for sharing informative updates. I would also suggest please do visit my blog for amazing information I am publishing on daily basis.
Tomas Murphy wrote on 18 May 2023:
This article is really amazing. Thanks for the sharing.Really nice style and perfectly written content material in this. Material on this page is very efficient I’ve ever had.We do not need anything else. Thank you so much for the information.
casinositewiki wrote on 18 May 2023:
This is an excellent post I seen, thanks that you share it with us very good youtube
oncasinosite wrote on 18 May 2023:
Thanks a lot for the blog. Thanks Again. Want more. youtube
casinositetop wrote on 18 May 2023:
Thank you ever so much for your blog post. Really thank you! Really Cool. youtube
casinositeking wrote on 18 May 2023:
Appreciate you sharing, great article post. Much thanks again. Fantastic. youtube
kalona3310 wrote on 18 May 2023:
The EHallPass platforms typically allow students and staff to submit their pass requests online, and the requests are reviewed and approved by designated personnel.
CLICK HERE = EHallPass
Bushra wrote on 23 May 2023:
Nice Informative Blog having nice sharing.. Jaipur Model escort Service
Bushra wrote on 23 May 2023:
i read a lot of stuff and i found that the way of writing to clearifing that exactly want to say was very good so i am impressed and ilike to come again in future.. jokowi kontol
Naveedmughal wrote on 24 May 2023:
Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here… ceramic pipes
asimseo wrote on 25 May 2023:
landscape companies near me Thank you for the update, very nice site..
asimseo wrote on 25 May 2023:
Thank you for the update, very nice site.. landscape companies near me
Bushra wrote on 26 May 2023:
thank you for a great post. Buy THC Vape Carts Online in NE
Daisy Thomas wrote on 26 May 2023:
One of the most critical tasks in making sure your dissertation is flawless and of the greatest calibre is proofreading it. Finding a dissertation proofreading service that matches your demands can be challenging with the variety of services offered. Fortunately, there are a few essential aspects to take into account when choosing a proofreading service, including their experience and skill, response time, accuracy rate, and customer service. You can make sure that you choose the dissertation proofreading services for your project by taking these considerations into account.
shaikh seo wrote on 27 May 2023:
Thank you very much for the sharing! COOL.. Hotels in Oslo
John wrote on 30 May 2023:
Thanks for the sharing great stuff. I found lot of interesting information from your post.
Bushra wrote on 31 May 2023:
This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It is the old what goes around comes around routine. lords exchange
Bushra wrote on 1 June 2023:
Nice Informative Blog having nice sharing.. Scrap Car Removal Chilliwack
Bushra wrote on 1 June 2023:
thank you for a great post. scrap car removal Burnaby
Bushra wrote on 2 June 2023:
Nice Informative Blog having nice sharing.. https://www.rtps-instanslot.xn--6frz82g/
CV writing services Ireland wrote on 3 June 2023:
Our CV services are available near you, so you can easily access the assistance you need. From writing and revamping your CV to creating a professional CV from scratch, we provide comprehensive help to make your CV stand out. Visit cv writing for me
Greece Assignment Help wrote on 3 June 2023:
Looking for dissertation proofreading and editing services Greece? Trust our experienced professionals to refine your work to perfection. Get accurate and reliable assistance to enhance the quality of your research and make it shine.
asimseo wrote on 3 June 2023:
Wow i will say that that is yet another good report not surprisingly of the blog.Bookmarked that site.. things you want in real estate investment software
Bushra wrote on 3 June 2023:
Thanks for your information, it was really very helpfull.. Info over Dormicum kopen
Bushra wrote on 4 June 2023:
Most of the time I don’t make comments on websites, but I’d like to say that this article really forced me to do so. Really nice post! Prenatal & Postnatal Yoga Teacher Training 2023-24
Bushra wrote on 4 June 2023:
Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. 300 Hour Yoga Teacher Training in Rishikesh
Bushra wrote on 4 June 2023:
Thanks for sharing the info, keep up the good work going…. I really enjoyed exploring your site. good resource… jaipur model escort
Bushra wrote on 4 June 2023:
Thanks for your information, it was really very helpfull.. 200 hours yoga teacher training in Rishikesh
asimseo wrote on 5 June 2023:
What a fantabulous post this has been. Never seen this kind of useful post. I am grateful to you and expect more number of posts like these. Thank you very much. housing loan interest
Assignment Helper Malaysia wrote on 5 June 2023:
Assignment Helper Malaysia is a leading homework helper in Malaysia that has been assisting students in their academic pursuits for several years. With a team of experienced and qualified tutors, the platform provides high-quality homework help services to students from different academic levels and disciplines.
Bushra wrote on 7 June 2023:
Platecor en una asesoría y gestoría en Córdoba capital. Está especializada en administración de fincas, comunidades de vecinos; además son expertos asesoría fiscal, contable, técnica y empresas. Gestión de comunidades en Córdoba
Akun Pro Thailand wrote on 7 June 2023:
slot-thailand merupakan slot online terpercaya dan terbaik yang sudah terbukti gacornya, banyak keuntungan besar yang bisa Anda dapatkan ketika bergabung di situs resmi kami.tidak perlu takut mengalami kerugian selama Anda bermain di situs Kami Sudah Terpercaya Dan Aman.
Situs judi online Merupakan Game Judi Bola Online terpopuler di situs Agen Bola Piala Dunia Terpercaya 2023 dan dijamin bisa maxwin,banyak scatter yang bisa Anda dapatkan ketika sedang memainkan slot game pada situs Kudabet.