X Close

Emerging Subjects Blog

Home

Emerging Subjects of the New Economy: Tracing Economic Growth in Mongolia

Menu

The Road to Power

By uczipm0, on 24 August 2016

This is the third in a series of posts about Mongolia’s 2016 parliamentary elections that were held on June 29th.

This post was written by Liz Fox, a UCL ESRC-funded anthropology PhD candidate affiliated to the Emerging Subjects project. Liz is completing the final stage of her doctoral research in Mongolia.

 

There’s a new road in Aglag District.[1]

When the diggers suddenly appeared one evening at the end of May, the area was filled with discussion over whether the road would be paved or not. What needed no discussion, however, was why, suddenly this May someone from the government had decided that the nearly impassable central artery through this Ulaanbaatar ger district finally needed attending to. That was obvious: the June election.

The arrival of trucks of gravel and sun-blackened workers was followed shortly by a sudden rush to open and occupy abandoned shops and office spaces. Flags and banners appeared outside these doors, as did flyer-distributing pairs in colour-coordinated baseball caps. The billboards at the bus terminals became decked with the photo-shopped faces of parliamentary candidates, micro buses topped with loudspeakers whirled around the open space and up and down the dirt roads. Election fever came fast and loud to Aglag, a dramatic transformation for the normally remote and dusty district.

The candidate selection in Aglag was remarkably diverse. Residents had the choice between household names from the world of television, film, music, and art, the children of big business figures, intellectuals educated abroad and a well-established political incumbent. The fundamental choice, however, was tripartite: to re-elect the ruling Democratic Party, to return the People’s Party to power after a 4-year absence, or to take a chance on a small party or independent candidate.

For the unemployed and chronically underemployed, election rallies are a good way to pass the time. Families attended meetings by both major parties, and those held by particularly famous independent candidates. The speakers were duly listened to, the disparities between their faces on the posters and in the flesh were commented on, the local drunks who dominated the microphones when the candidates opened the floor to residents were at turns held to be funny or embarrassing, and at the end, as we walked away on the half-finished new road, the same feeling was voiced: “Yes, they speak very nicely, but will they actually do anything for us?”

What a candidate will actually deliver is a question that many Mongolians were asking as they came to a decision over who to vote for. However, I would argue that it is a question that those with socio-economic power were asking with some certainty, and those living in ger districts were asking with near total disillusionment. This assertion leads to the central working argument of this post:

The notion of voter ‘choice’ in Mongolia is complicated by three factors: 1. the disconnection of political ideology from the major political parties, 2. the forces at work that influence voting through semi- and non-legal means, and 3. a phenomenon I will call “the inverted logic of the vote-return exchange”.

 

Political Disconnection

Almost no one I speak to in Mongolia seems to think about the two major parties as distinct ideological entities: politics is just politicians. Especially among disenfranchised ger district residents, people see politicians as powerful people looking to benefit themselves and their relatives and allies. It doesn’t matter what party they are from. Joining a party is just a decision driven by personal political motives, not a demonstration of allegiance to any particular world-view.

Of course, there are people who are very passionately involved in a party here and may have always been. But, at least in Aglag District, people usually do not start in one camp or another or even know how to define one party from the other. There is no ‘package’ of related political ideals that people from one side or another cleave to with the near-religious conviction witnessed, for example, in the UK referendum and US election campaigns that were taking place at the same time. Instead, people ask the pragmatic question: what was delivered over the last four years? Who do we think will deliver more for us over the next four? In fact some families have voted for three different parties over the last three elections.

 

Locust Migration: Tricks of the Trade

Mongolians are well aware of the semi- and non-legal goings on that take place in the lead up to an election. The stream of leaked videos and audio recordings that fill the news reports and invite endless online discussion fuels the general disillusionment and disappointment in the country’s political situation. There are a number of tricky practices that are carried out in order to tip the balance of the election one way or another. One is well-known enough to have been given its own nickname: tsartsaani nvvdel, locust migration. This evocative term refers to the ‘moving’ of people from one district to another for the sole purpose of voting. Shortly before the election citizens are moved on paper and will be re-located after they give their vote. Although laws are in place that put a hold on registering a change of location in the run up to the election day, they only stop those that do move from voting in the new district’s local government election. The parliamentary election is still open to influence.

Institutions carry out wholesale address changes. On election day buses are ordered to take entire companies from one district to another, or even all the way out into the countryside and the ‘locusts’ are clearly instructed on which party to vote for. Some people brought into these schemes by their bosses say that they ‘know’ that they have a free vote in the district they have been moved into, whereas others say they ‘know’ that if they don’t vote for the candidate they’ve been instructed to, their bosses will find out someway or another and they’ll lose their job.

 

The Inverted Logic of the Vote-Return Exchange

In democratic elections, there is a logic to the relationship between pre-election promises and post-election action.  Usually, it goes like this: to win a vote you have to make the right promises about what you are going to do after you are elected. If the public gives you the vote, you return the favour by fulfilling your promises to them.  I argue that in Mongolia, things are currently working in reverse in terms of the timing and direction of ‘giving’.

Instead of exchanging promises for votes, which then are returned as political action, candidates here give things to the voters (the ‘return’) before the election. They spend vast sums of money to encourage a vote for themselves, and then once they are elected, it’s the public’s turn to give back so that the politician can recoup the loses s/he incurred during the campaign and build further power and influence.

One example of this reverse logic in action is the new road. It was promised years ago, but was only delivered just before the election. Local residents commented at length on the timing and speed of its delivery: “Look, this road could have been done in a couple weeks, years ago! They are doing it right now so that we’ll vote for them. But if we take the gift now, we’ll be the one’s who pay later; as we did for the last 4 years. The politicians made themselves richer and richer while we got poorer and poorer.”

In his speech at the opening of the 2016 Mongolian Economic Forum, President Elbegdorj also alluded to the effects of this logic when he criticised the trend of failed businesspeople going into politics. They do so, the president said, because the power they serve to gain will give them an opportunity to rebuild their own wealth. You will have to spend money to gain power, but once you do, it will be time to give back, not to those that voted for you, but your own network of relatives and allies.

 

Personal Pragmatic Voting

When politics is politicians, and voters are bussed from here to there, I would argue an intensely personal and pragmatic logic takes over. Most people in the upper socioeconomic brackets have a relative somewhere involved in politics and they are therefore both on the one hand obliged to vote for them, and on the other hand, have the most to potentially gain from supporting that relative into power. Even the rich who are disillusioned about the state of politics and complain that their own relatives seem never to be satisfied still admit that, when it comes down to it, you vote for who you have to. For the poorer ger district residents, what happens before the election may be more beneficial for them than what happens after. Due to the inverted logic, the disenfranchised serve to gain more while politicians court their votes. Once they are elected, people say they will only serve themselves.

In the end, they didn’t pave the new road in Aglag District and after only a few days of heavy rain, its surface quickly deteriorated.

But then again, one road wasn’t enough to get the Democratic Party re-elected there anyway.

 

[1] All names and locations have been changed.

Thank you to G. Gerelsuren for contributing research to the piece.

 

132 Responses to “The Road to Power”

  • 1
    James McCormack wrote on 24 August 2016:

    Excellent writing.
    Unfortunate description of Mongolian lemmings.
    Well done.
    How can they improve their lot? They trashed the DP.
    Will MPP be any different?

  • 2
    valerie_valival wrote on 26 August 2016:

    This is a true account by Liz Fox who has spent many years in Mongolia.. A part of the world which is not often recognised by the west who need your support to help Mongolians to a better life in a political life that serves all

  • 3
    How Gifts Grant Candidates Power | UCL Emerging Subjects Blog wrote on 1 September 2016:

    […] who “does a lot of things” (ih yum hiisen).  As Liz Fox described in her recent blog post, The Road to Power, being someone who has done something, not someone who says they will do something, matters greatly […]

  • 4
    How Gifts Grant Candidates Power | Шинжээч – Үндэстний Сэргэн Мандлын Сүлжээ wrote on 8 September 2016:

    […] who “does a lot of things” (ih yum hiisen).  As Liz Fox described in her recent blog post, The Road to Power, being someone who has done something, not someone who says they will do something, matters greatly […]

  • 5
    baccarat online wrote on 23 February 2023:

    Of course, your article is good enough, baccarat online but I thought it would be much better to see professional photos and videos together. There are articles and photos on these topics on my homepage, so please visit and share your opinions.

  • 6
    sania khatri wrote on 23 February 2023:

    Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject buy cheap pubg uc in Pakistan

  • 7
    Gb whatsapp download wrote on 27 February 2023:

    Thanks for sharing this article here about the VPS. Your article is very informative and I will share it with my other friends as the information is really very useful. Keep sharing your excellent work.Gb whatsapp download

  • 8
    陸劇線上看 wrote on 27 February 2023:

    楊志剛, ,石悅安鑫, 王勁松,範明,嶽麗娜,陸劇線上看 超,奚望,吳春怡,韓承羽,姬晨牧,任希鴻,馮玉璽,白慶琳,李星昊

  • 9
    비아그라 wrote on 28 February 2023:

    Leterugendinkwaarhetdieengelvirjouge비아그라 사이트winkwaardiereenboogjousalvind.

  • 10
    시알리스사이트 wrote on 28 February 2023:

    Letefgdrugendinksgdwaarhetdieengelvirjouge시알리스사이트winkwaardiereenboogjousalvind.

  • 11
    baccaratcommunity wrote on 1 March 2023:

    I am very impressed with your writing baccaratcommunity I couldn’t think of this, but it’s amazing! I wrote several posts similar to this one, but please come and see!

  • 12
    altcoin pro wealth wrote on 1 March 2023:

    Bitcoin has altered the way traditional investors think about and construct their portfolios. altcoin pro wealth

  • 13
    bitcode ai wrote on 1 March 2023:

    This was a bit suspicious at first, but if you do your research you will find that the greater the volume of investors using the trading system, the better the margins. bitcode ai

  • 14
    collagen powder wrote on 2 March 2023:

    We believe adding Secret Labs® to your daily routine will do just that, and buying direct from Secret Labs® means collagen powder

  • 15
    collagen sachets wrote on 2 March 2023:

    Welcome to the Secret Labs® Organisation. We are specialist in Anti-Ageing and Health supplements. collagen sachets

  • 16
    suka main wrote on 3 March 2023:

    You can play international online slots that provide many benefits using only local banks and ewallets akun pro kamboja

  • 17
    remove moles at home wrote on 5 March 2023:

    Thuja occidentalis is one such ingredient with the main action being on the skin & includes nevus/nevi (the Latin name for mole/moles).* remove moles at home

  • 18
    baccaratsite wrote on 8 March 2023:

    I’ve been looking for photos and articles on this topic over the past few days due to a school assignment, baccaratsite and I’m really happy to find a post with the material I was looking for! I bookmark and will come often! Thanks 😀

  • 19
    hentai hube wrote on 8 March 2023:

    I trully appreciate your work and tips given by you is helpful to me hentai hube

  • 20
    韓劇網 wrote on 10 March 2023:

    Thanks to admin Nice work. 韓劇網

  • 21
    dramasq wrote on 10 March 2023:

    Appriciate to admin Amazing work. dramasq

  • 22
    dramasq wrote on 10 March 2023:

    Nice Article Appriciate to admin Nice work Amazing. dramasq

  • 23
    부산출장마사지 wrote on 11 March 2023:

    Find it a necessary discussion. Tricks of the Trade” refers to the insider knowledge and techniques that are passed down among experienced professionals in a particular industry or field, providing valuable shortcuts and insights that can help newcomers to succeed. While some may view these tricks as unethical or manipulative, they can often be the key to unlocking success in a competitive and rapidly changing world. You can visit 부산출장

  • 24
  • 25
  • 26
    Jazmin wrote on 16 March 2023:

    Jazmin Clothing offers a beautifully crafted lawn collection that exudes elegance and comfort. Discover the latest lawn designs at Jazmin Clothing and elevate your wardrobe to new heights of sophistication. Shop now and embrace the summer season in style.

  • 27
    baccaratsite wrote on 20 March 2023:

    It’s really great. Thank you for providing a quality article. There is something you might be interested in. Do you know baccaratsite ? If you have more questions, please come to my site and check it out!

  • 28
    sania khatri wrote on 20 March 2023:

    Superbly written article, if only all bloggers offered the same content as you, the internet would be a far better place. iphone xs max

  • 29
    sania khatri wrote on 21 March 2023:

    very nice and great article, thanks for sharing with us! gionee s9

  • 30
    sania khatri wrote on 21 March 2023:

    A decent blog dependably concocts new and energizing data and keeping in mind that understanding I have feel that this blog is truly have each one of those quality that qualify a blog to be a one. iphone 6 plus price in bangladesh

  • 31
    baccaratcommunity wrote on 22 March 2023:

    I’ve been looking for photos and articles on this topic over the past few days due to a school assignment, baccaratcommunity and I’m really happy to find a post with the material I was looking for! I bookmark and will come often! Thanks 😀

  • 32
    chochox wrote on 22 March 2023:

    Howdy! I simply want to give you a big thumbs up for your great information you have right here on this post chochox

  • 33
    sportstoto365 wrote on 23 March 2023:

    “It’s really good to build up information knowledge. My hobby is web surfing. If I have a chance, I will visit you again. The website is really cool. But its necessary to click the link below 토토사이트

  • 34
    powerballsite wrote on 23 March 2023:

    “Keep up the good work , I read few blog posts on this website and I believe that your weblog is rattling interesting. Thank you for this effort, I will give you 5 stars for this. Kindly check the link below Thank you! 파워볼사이트

  • 35
    totosafeguide wrote on 23 March 2023:

    “I was able to think a lot while looking at this post.
    I will pass this blog to many people. Definitely a good blog is very good. Thank you for sharing. 먹튀검증

  • 36
    totositerank wrote on 23 March 2023:

    “Thanks for sharing not only the good, but the hard and the bad as well. People look one way from the outside: accomplished, confident, whatever. It’s a gift that you share the fears and insecurities with your readers too. 스포츠토토

  • 37
    sania kh khatri wrote on 23 March 2023:

    useful post! Nice words and brilliant design redmi note 9 pro price in sri lanka

  • 38
    토토 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    I feel extremely cheerful to have se 토토

  • 39
    토토궁 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    short of brilliant in many ways. I think this is engaging and eye-opening material. Thank you so much for caring about your content and your readers . 토토궁

  • 40
    토담토담토토 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    I truly welcome this superb post that you have accommodated us. I guarantee this would be valuable for the vast majority 토담토담토토

  • 41
    먹튀패스 먹튀검증업체 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    . I will keep visiting this blog very often. Great job for publishing such a beneficial web site. Your web log isn’t only useful but it is additionally really creative too. 먹튀패스 먹튀검증업체

  • 42
    카지노 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    I had attempt to advance your own article in to delicius all things considered it’s anything but a predicament utilizing your data destinations would you be able to please reverify the thought. much appreciated again 카지노

  • 43
    토토위젯 검증업체 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    This is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the good work. I have been meaning to write something like this on my website and you have given me an idea. Better than normal Blog Post And Good Quality Content, this was a brief substance for me and everyone. you should keep sharing such a substance. I think this is a sublime article, and the content published is fantastic. This content will help me to complete a paper that I’ve been working on for the last 2 weeks. It was a difficult 2 weeks, but I am glad the work is done now. 토토위젯 검증업체

  • 44
    토스타 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    A lower level of stress can be relieved with some activities. However, excessive stress can affect the daily life of the students along with their mental and physical health. If you are also a student and feeling stressed due to academic reasons then contact online assignment help services today. I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work. Wow, excellent post. I’d like to draft like this too – taking time and real hard work to make a great article. This post has encouraged me to write some posts that I am going to write soon. 토스타

  • 45
    먹튀프렌즈검증업체 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work. I would also motivate just about every person to save this web page for any favorite assistance to assist posted the appearance. 먹튀프렌즈검증업체

  • 46
    토토 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    Great day I am so charmed I found your weblog, I truly discovered you unintentionally, while I was exploring on Digg for something different, Nonetheless I am here now and might simply want to say an abundance of thanks for a noteworthy post and an inside and out fascinating site (I additionally love the topic/plan), I donít have the opportunity to peruse everything at the moment yet I have bookmarked it and furthermore added your RSS channels, so when I have time I will have returned to peruse significantly more, Please keep up the fabulous work. Hello I realize this is off theme yet I was contemplating whether you was aware of any gadgets I could add to my blog that naturally tweet my freshest twitter refreshes. I’ve been searching for a module like this for a long while and was trusting possibly you would have some involvement in something like this. Kindly let me know whether you run into anything. I really appreciate perusing your blog and I anticipate your new updates.| This is an extraordinary blog. 토토

  • 47
    먹튀 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    Howdy! I’m grinding away surfing around your blog from my new apple iphone! Simply needed to say I love perusing your blog and anticipate every one of your posts! Keep up the remarkable work!| I simply needed to foster a short note to thank you for the entirety of the incredible strategies you are composing here. My long web query has now been compensated with acceptable understanding to discuss with my companions and colleagues. I ‘d say that the majority of us guests are amazingly honored to abide in an eminent spot with numerous unique people with supportive ideas. I feel very fortunate to have utilized your site and anticipate a lot of more fun occasions perusing here. Much obliged to you again for a great deal of things. Woah! I’m truly adoring the layout/subject of this blog. It’s straightforward, yet successful. A great deal of times it’s exceptionally hard to get that wonderful equilibrium” between heavenly ease of use and appearance. I should say you have worked really hard with this. Also, the blog stacks very quick for me on Chrome. Heavenly Blog! 먹튀

  • 48
    토토 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. Greetings to each one, it’s really a particular for me to visit this website page, it comprises of helpful Information. Just pure brilliance from you here. I have never expected something less than this from you and you have not disappointed me at all. I suppose you will keep the quality work going on. This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, These type of articles keeps the users interest in the website, and keep on sharing more … good luck. Thanks a lot for one’s intriguing write-up. It’s actually exceptional. Searching ahead for this sort of revisions. 토토

  • 49
    토토사이트먹튀 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    Thanks a lot for one’s intriguing write-up. It’s actually exceptional. Searching ahead for this sort of revisions. 토토사이트먹튀

  • 50
    메이저사이트 wrote on 26 March 2023:

    I expected to make you the little comment just to express profound gratitude a ton indeed about the striking assessments you’ve recorded메이저사이트