Internalizing External Debt
By Lauren Bonilla, on 24 February 2016
This is the final blog post in our series about loans and debt.
“Did you read the news about Oyu Tolgoi?”, asked Ganzorig between sips of green tea. Assuming that his question referred to the news announced the previous day that the Mongolian government signed a major financing agreement to begin development of the underground section of the Oyu Tolgoi copper-gold deposit in Omnogobi province, I replied, “Yes, it’s big news for Mongolia.”
Ganzorig exhaled sharply and shook his head, remarking in a dispirited tone, “It’s not so good for us.” His negative response took me by surprise. In the twelve years Ganzorig and I have been friends, he has had a consistently optimistic attitude towards Oyu Tolgoi and its contribution to his country’s development. When I asked Ganzorig why the deal was not good, he clarified his sentiments:
It’s another loan. It’s like 4 billion American dollars, right? How can we repay this? Uh, there are too many loans!
Later that day, I met with a former colleague working in the tourism industry who, like Ganzorig, brought up the news about Oyu Tolgoi and was quick to criticize it. She lamented, “My country will pay more for loans than become rich from Oyu Tolgoi!”
These were offhand comments made by friends in casual conversations, yet I think they reveal something significant that is forming in the minds of many Mongolians around the rising indebtedness of their country.
A New Debt Landscape
In 2011 and 2012, when I conducted research on the growth of the mining industry, I heard little public discussion about debt and loans in relation to the mining industry and the national economy more broadly. Of course, mining companies at the time were engaged in a wide range of official and unofficial lending practices to finance operations, and there were important discussions between companies (both foreign and domestic) and the government about who should bear the responsibility of financing mining projects and ancillary infrastructures. However, in interviews with a number of diverse Mongolians living in different regions of the country, I found that people were more interested in the then hot-topic of national equity ownership in mining projects like Oyu Tolgoi than about the loans required to make such projects possible.
When I returned to Mongolia in the fall, I observed how discussion about national-level debts filled evening news programs, came up in crowded jeep rides across the countryside, and figured into intimate conversations among family and friends. Far from being an abstract issue for government and economic policy, ‘foreign debt’ (gadaad ör) and ‘national/state debt’ (ulsyn/töriin ör) appears to be becoming internalized in people’s lives as a new economic reality and a subject of collective concern.
The Chinggis Bond Effect
Rising public awareness of national-level debts reveals how Mongolia’s relationship with debt has changed in recent years. In 2012, the Mongolian government acquired its first sovereign bond, nicknamed the ‘Chinggis Bond’. Sold as a five- and ten-year bond, it garnered US$1.5 billion, far more than was initially anticipated. A year later, the Development Bank of Mongolia issued a ¥30 billion 10-year ‘Samurai Bond’ in Japan. The word ‘bond’ has since become normalized in colloquial Mongolian, referring specifically to a loan financed by investors on international markets. More generally, and perhaps significantly, bond is also used to refer to debt that Mongolia, as a nation, owes to foreigners.
The debts raised by the two sovereign bonds are small in comparison to the national debts of other nations – a point Mongolian politicians and economists commonly make. Their significance, though, is compounded by other external debts acquired by the government and companies, especially miners. The timing of this debt accumulation is significant, as it has occurred not in a period of growth but amid the slowdown of the Chinese economy and the global commodity cycle, two interrelated dynamics to which Mongolia is exceptionally exposed. According to a report published in November by Fitch, Mongolia now has the second highest external debt to GDP ratio in the world at 129.8%, representing some $22 billion.
Personal as National Debt
This amount of debt could feel distant to an individual, like how, as an American, the US national debt of $16.3 trillion feels to me. However, I think that many Mongolians can relate to this debt because it reflects the indebtedness they feel in their own life, albeit on a much larger scale.
When Ganzorig expressed to me that there are “too many loans,” he was directly commenting on the large amount of foreign debt his country was accumulating. Knowing Ganzorig well, I could also hear the words reflecting his frustration with living a life where he is constantly swapping one loan for the next, slowly building more and more debts in the process.
Ganzorig struggles to operate a small electrical business in Ulaanbaatar, often relying on small loans, barter, and gifts from friends to get projects done. He could not get a business loan from a bank because he had no office property to serve as collateral. He could not acquire an office because he is already plagued with stress and sleepless nights about how to pay a hefty monthly mortgage on an apartment he bought a couple years ago through the 8% mortgage scheme. Additionally, following the government’s adoption of a new tax law last August to get tax revenues from businesses, Ganzorig has been under pressure to pay taxes he did not know he owed to a local municipality.
He described to me how any money coming to him feels like it goes “undigested” (shingeegüi): it runs right through him like his stomach was upset, thereby providing him no nutritional gain. Any “profit” (ashig) goes “to the bank” through interest payments, allowing a small group of elites to “keep money in their pockets.”
Moreover, for someone like Ganzorig whose everyday life is already shaped by chains of debt, national debt might feel like yet another link that weighs the chain down. Yet it is a link that is not necessarily of one’s choosing, given that debt like the Chinggis Bond is classified as ‘public property‘ (ard tümnii ömch) to be repaid through taxes and the state budget.
Given the public ownership of bond monies, how the monies have been spent since 2012 has been a topic of controversy. Originally, the bonds were meant to finance national development projects, like the construction of roads and bridges, the building of factories, the improvement in energy and electrical infrastructures, and the financing of small enterprises. The government stated that it planned to use the Chinggis Bond to fund 888 projects, a number that my research partner, G. Munkherdene, explained to me, “Was chosen because of its spiritual importance…it was seen as lucky.”
Rumors and conspiracy theories abound about how the allocation of bond monies was based on political and business alliances and secret deals instead of transparent and egalitarian tender processes. Indeed, when the majority of politicians are also involved in private businesses – a phenomenon Bum-Ochir Dulam explored in his post on the mortgage market – any government-backed economic project appears suspicious.
In Ulaanbaatar, my friends point out features of the urban landscape that they associate with the bonds: smiling faces painted on sewer covers, empty apartment buildings, new roads and bridges, and pedestrian cross walks. In rural western Mongolia, people also pointed out similar new features in their district center that they thought were built with government-backed ‘projects’ (tösöl) funded by the Chinggis bond. While these improvements seemed welcomed, people wondered about where the rest of the bond monies have disappeared and why long-term things that would make Mongolia more productive in the future (heregtei yum) – like better hospitals and schools, and more domestic industry and jobs – have not been developed. A smiling face on a sewer cover does little to help someone pay their own debts, let alone the nation’s.
‘#Hyamral #Hyamdral #Hyatad’
In November, Khongorzul Bat-Ireedui, a rising public figure in Mongolia, posted the following message to her many followers on Facebook and Twitter:
The message about GDP growth and the clever alliteration of words at the bottom, which can be translated as #crisis #sale #China, reflects the kind of grim expectations Mongolians have for 2016.
The IMF/World Bank warns that Mongolia is at risk of ‘debt distress’ because of its mounting external debts, declining foreign investment and revenues from mining, and looming debt repayments. In 2017, $500 million from the Chinggis bond and a $580 million government-guaranteed bond through the Development Bank of Mongolia are owed to creditors. US$2.4 billion from a three-year currency swap with the People’s Bank of China is also due, though this is anticipated to be extended into the future. Given the widely discussed lack of liquidity in Mongolia, how these debt are to be repaid is contested and uncertain (see here and here).
Since Ch. Saihanbileg became Prime Minister in November 2014, the government has declared that there is now an ‘economic crisis’ (ediin zasgiin hyamral) in Mongolia that must be managed. ‘Debt distress’ is part of the crisis, but there are also wider economic challenges that Mongolians are feeling in very tangible ways. The value of the Mongolian tögrög is regularly hitting new historic lows, herders are selling animal meat and skins at the worst prices in memory, salaries have been cut or suspended across a number of sectors, and people have lost jobs amid the retreat of foreign investors. If you get into a taxi cab in Ulaanbaatar and ask the driver about the economy – he or she will very likely describe it to you as hyamral, a crisis.
It seems, too, that the language of crisis has as much to do with future expectations as about the current condition. Khongorzul may be suggesting this by flagging the words “discount” and “China”, given that there is widespread anticipation – and outright fear – that the Mongolian government will address its debt distress by giving away its mineral wealth to China for little or nothing in return for financial assistance.
These dynamics paint quite a negative picture for 2016. Mongolian astrologers are calling this new lunar year of the fire monkey ‘evil faced’ (muu nüürt or nüür muut) because it is expected to bring low precipitation and poor forage for livestock, and an increase in political struggles and poverty, among other things. The upcoming parliamentary election this summer also adds weight to the year, as election seasons are often times when much happens and is promised.
It will be important to watch how Mongolian politicians address the issue of debt this year. There are some individuals who seek to make the looming debt repayments seem less severe and manageable, whereas others seek to increase public awareness about their size and significance. Either way, it is a highly politicized field.
Moreover, how ordinary Mongolians negotiate national debt is perhaps an even more interesting question. As my colleague, Bum-Ochir Dulam, put it while we chatted about this topic in our office at UCL:
We [Mongolians] are all socially bonded by the Chinggis Bond. I have debt, our nation has debt, we all have debt.
It is not only that so many Mongolians carry personal debts, but that individuals feel that they share in the responsibility of repaying national debts. This responsibility may take the form of austerity measures, like increased taxation, budget cuts, and job losses. Or it may be more direct, such as the government calculating the amount of national debt to be allocated to every Mongolian, even newborn children – a scheme that is reputedly underway. Mongolians are also concerned that they will be implicated in governmental actions that they personally oppose and which might affect the fortune and future of their nation. For instance, subsoil wealth, like the gold deposits near Noyon Uul, may be extracted not for development purposes, but to pay off debts to foreigners.
A Space for New Citizen Politics?
Our blog series has documented the pervasiveness of loans and debt in Mongolia. While lending practices and debts are not necessarily seen as negative, and can even help build new forms of sociality and economic possibility, the cumulative impact of personal, business, and national debts is uncertain.
As seen in other places where rising national and personal debts have become touchstone issues, debt can be a galvanizing societal force that can lead to popular uprisings, movements, and regime changes. In Mongolia, where the government has never had to be dependent on nor be accountable to citizens through public taxation, given its access to other revenue streams, the shared experience of being ‘collective owners’ of national debt may open the space for new forms of citizen politics. Mongolians may question their entanglement in their nation’s debts – which they never asked for in the first place – and why they and perhaps future generations should bear the debt burden.
Conversations about debt with my research partners, Sh. Tuya and G. Munkherdene, contributed to this post.
 Domestic and foreign companies commonly viewed the government as seeking to bear as little debt as possible.
 ‘Foreign debt’ and ‘national/state debt’ are sometimes used interchangeably in Mongolia. Foreign debt can include both public and private debts obtained abroad. National/state debt refers to monies which the government has borrowed (which, in the case of Mongolia, is primarily sourced abroad). When the government borrows money externally through a bond, the debt is known as sovereign debt. For simplicity and to reflect how Mongolians themselves commonly talk about national-level debts, I use ‘national debt’ in this blog post.
 It is difficult to find consistent figures of Mongolia’s total external debt. Different entities in Mongolia like the Ministry of Finance, researchers, politicians, and the IMF/World Bank classify national debt using different metrics. For instance, some calculate currency swaps as part of state debt, whereas others do not. Mongolia revised its Debt Management Plan in 2015 in an attempt to clarify the issue.
 Someone who “keeps money in their pocket” is often seen in a negative light as ‘stingy’ (haramch). Someone who redistributes personal monies through loans or gifts to friends and relatives is a characteristic of a ‘good person’ (sain hün).
 Data on the amount of this currency swap varies. In a parliamentary meeting, the value was put at $1.9 billion.
171 Responses to “Internalizing External Debt”
Meena Singh wrote on 18 April 2023:
You’ll release tension from your muscles as the therapist manipulates and kneads your muscles. As your mind and body relax, you may feel a sense calmness and relaxation. Massage spa chennai
Ramon Miles wrote on 18 April 2023:
Maximizing the impact of your voice-over with sound design can elevate the overall quality and effectiveness of your audio production. By carefully selecting and crafting sound effects, music, and ambience, you can create a more immersive and engaging listening experience. Effective sound design can also help convey emotions and reinforce messaging, making your voice over service more memorable and impactful. So, don’t underestimate the power of sound design in enhancing your voice-over work.
Massage therapist wrote on 21 April 2023:
You’re probably looking for a rejuvenating and relaxing experience to relieve your stress and tension. B2B massage, or Massage near me, is a sensual form of massage where the therapist uses their own body to massage the client’s body. The goal is to create a closer connection and provide a more intimate massage experience.
sama wrote on 21 April 2023:
This is a fantastic website and I can not recommend you guys enough. simpla 360 erfahrungen
Emersyn wrote on 21 April 2023:
This is inspiring, keep on the good work. I comment whenever I like a post on a website or if I have something valuable to contribute to the discussion. I had a nice time surfing through your blog article. Thanks so much for sharing
uncontested divorce new jersey
safetotosite.pro wrote on 22 April 2023:
I’d want to thank you for writing such an interesting article on the issue. This has given me a lot to think about, 먹튀검증 and I’m excited to read more.
casinositenet.com wrote on 22 April 2023:
This is an awesome article,
카지노사이트넷 Given such an extraordinary measure of data in it, These sort of articles keeps the customers excitement for the site, and keep sharing more … favorable circumstances.
casinositekim.com wrote on 22 April 2023:
This is the one of the most important information for me. And I am feeling glad reading your article.
카지노사이트킴The article is really excellent.
Kavya Kaur wrote on 24 April 2023:
Another advantage of anHaridwar Escort Service for escorting is the convenience it provides. There are many services available 24 hours a day which means you can arrange your companionship at any point of night or day. Also, you don’t need to worry about travelling across long distances to meet your desired phone lady in Haridwar. All you have to do is to make arrangements and wait for the escort of your choice to arrive.
Deep Sharma wrote on 24 April 2023:
I appreciate the depth and breadth of your research, and your writing style is engaging and informative
เดิมพันกีฬาออนไลน์ wrote on 25 April 2023:
เว็บออนไลน์ต่างๆ เข้ามาที่นี่เลย ได้ค่าตอบแทนสูงที่นี่ที่เดียว เดิมพันกีฬาออนไลน์
vegita lawyer wrote on 25 April 2023:
Wow, I absolutely loved reading this blog post! Your writing style is engaging and easy to follow, and the content was informative and thought-provoking. It’s always refreshing to come across a positive and uplifting messageBest Divorce Lawyers Near Me
ลิ้งค์รับทรัพย์ igoal wrote on 26 April 2023:
This is very useful for me and I think your post is also useful for the world. Keep working hard if you want to advance in the future. Thanks again for the great post.
Addie Hogan wrote on 26 April 2023:
This is a really useful article. Thank you for providing these informative posts. dino game
Hyderabad Beauties wrote on 26 April 2023:
Really impressive post. I read it whole and going to Hyderabad escorts , share it with my social circulates. I enjoyed your article and planning to rewrite it on my own blog
Earley wrote on 28 April 2023:
I was very impressed by your writing. It’s amazing and inspiring. Really good stuff you have shared.
joseph mathew wrote on 29 April 2023:
Hi, your blog was interesting and informative , I enjoyed reading your blog , thanks for sharing , keep posting more blog Trust and Estate Lawyer
Emersyn wrote on 29 April 2023:
Thank you so much for sharing. Nice to reading blog post, Keep up good work
bankruptcy lawyers in lynchburg virginia
Sara Kaur wrote on 1 May 2023:
If you are thinking about hiring a Delhi Escorts, then you should definitely do some research to find the right escort for you. There are many escorts in Delhi, so you want to make sure you find one that you are comfortable with and that you feel confident with.
hulk brendan wrote on 1 May 2023:
With its exceptionally clear and straightforward writing style, the blog post makes for an enjoyable read, while also serving as an excellent source of valuable information for those interested in the topic. If you’re in the market for new waders, look no further than waterproofitexpert. Their dependable reviews can be trusted to help you make the best decision possible.
adamstack01 wrote on 5 May 2023:
If you’re looking for information on communicating with Sun Country Change Flight Policy, you’ve come to the right place. We can assist you in communicating with a Tar Sun Country Change Flight representative here.
Family Lawyer near me wrote on 5 May 2023:
It is an informative article which contains rich content. This post helps me to enrich my knowledge in specific topics. Thanks for sharing this informative content. Family Lawyer near me
Adult toys wrote on 6 May 2023:
Vibrators are one of the most popular types of adult toys and come in a variety of shapes and sizes. Some are designed for external stimulation of the clitoris, while others are designed for internal stimulation of the G-spot or other erogenous zones. Many vibrators have multiple vibration settings, allowing users to customize the intensity and speed of the vibrations. flamingo vibrator
healtipsandguide wrote on 6 May 2023:
The thought that diet can impact reproductive health worries many women. There is a pervasive misconception that some meals might have a detrimental impact on sperm production and even kill sperm in the female body. The reproduction process critically depends on the sperm’s health, and any harm to the sperm can reduce fertility. Health Tips and guide
Emily wilson wrote on 6 May 2023:
Great post! I really appreciate the insights you shared on this topic. Your writing is engaging and easy to follow, making it a pleasure to read. I particularly liked how you provided concrete examples to illustrate your points, which helped me better understand the concepts you were discussing. Thank you for taking the time to share your knowledge and expertise. hearsayincourt
Emma Harriet wrote on 8 May 2023:
¡Buen artículo! Realmente aprecio las ideas que ha compartido sobre este tema. Su escritura es cautivadora y fácil de chicas escort Avellaneda entender, por lo que es un placer leerla.
Plantlane Retail Private Limited wrote on 9 May 2023:
bird feeder price can vary in price depending on the type and quality.
Emma Harriet wrote on 10 May 2023:
Esta es una de las piezas de información chicas escort Tucuman más importantes para mí. Y estoy feliz de leer tu artículo.
John Morgan wrote on 10 May 2023:
Thanks for Sharing this post. The Financial Statement Analysis Assignment Help you have been looking for is here. Click here to find out the range of disciplines we would be happy to help you with.
divyarastogi wrote on 15 May 2023:
This article is intriguing and well-written, with a wealth of useful information that keeps readers interested. I appreciate the information and acknowledge your hard work on this. I know very well that if anyone visits your blog, he/she will get back to it.
Kolkata Female Escorts
Cillian wrote on 15 May 2023:
Hi, I’m Cillian Gallian a professional blogger, traveler, and writer trying to create a platform that will help people share their experiences, the places they visited, how they felt, and what they Would like to share on the blog. Currently, I am based in California, I am here to make some great connections with people from all over the world interested in traveling. If you have any questions related to Allegiant Air Pet Policy Please let me know as this is a common question for people.
William wrote on 15 May 2023:
THANKS FOR THIS BEAUTIFUL ARTICLE AND SO MUCH REALLY GREAT INFO ABOUT THIS. APPRECIATE IT.
abogado de lesiones personales de virginia
divorcio de virginia sin oposición wrote on 18 May 2023:
Thanks for sharing this wonderful tip! I agree that having a clear understanding about your article according to your customers’ needs and preferences, Overall, it’s great advice for everyone.divorcio de virginia sin oposición
massage with happy ending wrote on 19 May 2023:
get massage with happy ending service by nadnight near your locality by hot female therapist by afforadable prices.
Deniel Klane wrote on 19 May 2023:
Thanks so much for the nice ideas share in this blog post. I am sure this article has touched all the internet visitors. Thanks for sharing. Our Company provides Online College Paper help services.
raju wrote on 19 May 2023:
Thanks for sharing this post it’s all information is really helpful for all us.
abogado de lesiones personales de virginia
Design Fictives wrote on 22 May 2023:
Your blog is always a great source of information and inspiration. Keep up the fantastic work! Your company’s logo is a crucial part of your brand identity. A well-designed logo can instantly convey the history, story, and meaning of your brand with just a single glance. At Design Fictives, our expert logo designers combine creativity with the latest design trends to produce captivating and meaningful logos. We skillfully incorporate various elements such as symbols, calligraphy, and other artistic components to create a logo that leaves a long-lasting impression.
Deepa Sharma wrote on 22 May 2023:
Best and best call girls service provide a agra call me any time we are provide housewife and college girls russian escorts english call girls turkey and Spanish call girls Afghani also available at any time
kavya thakur wrote on 22 May 2023:
Goa Escorts Hot and sexy call girls best services you place so call me we are provide a hot and sexy college girls and model escorts provider free home delivery,
escort service in goa
Divya Sharma wrote on 22 May 2023:
one of the best call girls in noida
Mike Rooney wrote on 24 May 2023:
I found this post very exciting. I am also sending it to my friends to enjoy this blog.jack torrance jacket Replica
Andrew Mark wrote on 24 May 2023:
This is excellent article, thank you for the share! This is what I am looking for, hope in future you will continue sharing such an superb work.
The Shining Jacket
cryptorobotics wrote on 24 May 2023:
The article “Master Day Trading with Insights from Top Experts” provides valuable tips for improving day trading skills and performance. Here’s a summary of the nine tips mentioned. Educate Yourself: Understand the basics of the market, trading terminology, tools, and strategies. Take advantage of resources like books, websites, online courses, and trading simulators.
Myra Kapoor wrote on 25 May 2023:
The person will be able to do different things in the room when she is going to be there. The escort will be able to make you feel good about yourself after having some fun with them in your bedroom when they will leave after spending some time with you. Indian Web Series ||
Jameshunt10 wrote on 25 May 2023:
Welcome to Manthena American School, one of the top schools in Sharjah, offering a comprehensive education to students from all over the world. Our state-of-the-art campus is located in the heart of the Sharjah School Zone, and we are committed to providing our students with a safe and secure learning environment that promotes academic excellence, creativity, and innovation.
Visit our website for more info!
The creatives 360 wrote on 25 May 2023:
Discover the leading digital marketing agency in Sharjah, UAE, offering innovative strategies, creative solutions, and measurable results to help businesses thrive in the digital landscape. Trust their expertise to elevate your online presence and drive remarkable growth.
Our full-service digital marketing agency in Dubai & Sharjah offers a wide range of services to help you achieve your online marketing goals. Contact us today for the best digital marketing company in the UAE.email@example.com
+971 50 267 1236
deva wrote on 26 May 2023:
Thanks for being sharing such an extraordinary information.
But, Malviya Nagar escortgirls are one of the most welcoming. There’s plenty of employment opportunities for famous women and men to come to Malviya Nagar. The majority of these companies offer foreigners in a jumbled fashion in comparison to locals. You can check to determine whether you think the Malviya Nagar Call Girls you’re contacting are stunningly beautiful or not.