Close
Busting the 21 days habit formation myth
By Ben D Gardner, on 29 June 2012
Have you ever made a New Year’s resolution? If so, you may have been assured – usually by a well-meaning supporter of your attempted transformation – that you only have to stick with your resolution for 21 days for it to become an ingrained habit. The magic number 21 creeps up in many articles about forming a new habit or making a change, but little is known about the origins of the ’21 days’ claim.
Psychologists from our department have devoted extensive time and effort to find out what it takes to form ‘habits’ (which psychologists define as learned actions that are triggered automatically when we encounter the situation in which we’ve repeatedly done those actions).
We know that habits are formed through a process called ‘context-dependent repetition’. For example, imagine that, each time you get home each evening, you eat a snack. When you first eat the snack upon getting home, a mental link is formed between the context (getting home) and your response to that context (eating a snack). Each time you subsequently snack in response to getting home, this link strengthens, to the point that getting home comes to prompt you to eat a snack automatically, without giving it much prior thought; a habit has formed.
Habits are mentally efficient: the automation of frequent behaviours allows us to conserve the mental resources that we would otherwise use to monitor and control these behaviours, and deploy them on more difficult or novel tasks. Habits are likely to persist over time; because they are automatic and so do not rely on conscious thought, memory or willpower. This is why there is growing interest, both within and outside of psychology, in the role of ‘habits’ in sustaining our good behaviours.
So where does the magic ’21 days’ figure come from?
We think we have tracked down the source. In the preface to his 1960 book ‘Psycho-cybernetics’, Dr Maxwell Maltz, a plastic surgeon turned psychologist wrote:
‘It usually requires a minimum of about 21 days to effect any perceptible change in a mental image. Following plastic surgery it takes about 21 days for the average patient to get used to his new face. When an arm or leg is amputated the “phantom limb” persists for about 21 days. People must live in a new house for about three weeks before it begins to “seem like home”. These, and many other commonly observed phenomena tend to show that it requires a minimum of about 21 days for an old mental image to dissolve and a new one to jell.’ (pp xiii-xiv)
How anecdotal evidence from plastic surgery patients came to be generalised so broadly is unclear. One possibility is that the distinction between the term habituation (which refers to ‘getting used’ to something) and habit formation (which refers to the formation of a response elicited automatically by an associated situation) was lost in translation somewhere along the line. Alternatively, Maltz stated elsewhere that:
‘Our self-image and our habits tend to go together. Change one and you will automatically change the other.’ (p108)
Perhaps readers reasoned that, if self-image takes 21 days to change, and self-image changes necessarily lead to changes in habits, then habit formation must take 21 days. Although ‘21 days’ may perhaps apply to adjustment to plastic surgery, it is unfounded as a basis for habit formation. So, if not 21 days, then, how long does it really take to form a habit?
Researchers from our department have done a more rigorous and valid study of habit formation (Lally, van Jaarsveld, Potts, & Wardle, 2010). Participants performed a self-chosen health-promoting dietary or activity behaviour (e.g. drinking a glass of water) in response to a once-daily cue (e.g. after breakfast), and gave daily self-reports of how automatic (i.e. habitual) the behaviour felt. Participants were tracked for 84 days. Automaticity typically developed indistinct pattern: initial repetitions of the behaviour led to quite large increases in automaticity, but these increases then reduced in size the more often the behaviour was repeated, until automaticity plateaued. Assumed that the point, at which automaticity is highest, is also the point when the habit has formed, it took, on average, 66 days for the habit to form. (To clarify: that’s March 6th for anyone attempting a New Year’s resolution.)
Interestingly, however, there were quite large differences between individuals in how quickly automaticity reached its peak, although everyone repeated their chosen behaviour daily: for one person it took just 18 days, and another did not get there in the 84 days, but was forecast to do so after as long as 254 days.
There was also variation in how strong the habit became: for some people habit strength peaked below the halfway point of the 42-point strength scale and for others it peaked at the very top. It may be that some behaviours are more suited to habit formation – habit strength for simple behaviours (such as drinking a glass of water) peaked quicker than for more complex behaviours (e.g. doing 50 sit-ups) – or that people differ in how quickly they can form habits, and how strong those habits can become.
The bottom line is: stay strong. 21 days is a myth; habit formation typically takes longer than that. The best estimate is 66 days, but it’s unwise to attempt to assign a number to this process. The duration of habit formation is likely to differ depending on who you are and what you are trying to do. As long as you continue doing your new healthy behaviour consistently in a given situation, a habit will form. But you will probably have to persevere beyond January 21st.
Benjamin Gardner and Susanne Meisel
(www.ucl.ac.uk/hbrc/gardnerb)
References
Lally, P., van Jaarsveld, C. H. M., Potts, H. W. W., & Wardle, J. (2010). How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world. European Journal of Social Psychology, 40, 998-1009. (http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ejsp.674/abstract)
Maltz, M. (1960) Psycho-cybernetics. NJ: Prentice-Hall.
238 Responses to “Busting the 21 days habit formation myth”
- 1
-
2
No, 21 días no convierten un propósito en un hábito | TechBox wrote on 22 September 2015:
[…] En University College London, Busting the 21 days habit formation myth, […]
-
3
No, 21 días no convierten un propósito en un hábito | Ykaly wrote on 22 September 2015:
[…] En University College London, Busting the 21 days habit formation myth, […]
-
4
21 días no convierten un propósito en un hábito | Doble69™ wrote on 22 September 2015:
[…] En University College London, Busting the 21 days habit formation myth, […]
-
5
Vuoi Imparare A Vestire Meglio? 21 o 10.000? | Camiciaecravatta wrote on 1 October 2015:
[…] Qui puoi trovare il report della ricerca: blogs.ucl.ac.uk/hbrc/2012/06/29/busting-the-21-days-habit-formation-myth/ […]
-
6
El mito de los 21 días para “crear un hábito” | En tu mejor versión wrote on 23 October 2015:
[…] Nos gusta pensar que el cambio será rápido y de camino suave… y ahí es donde nos equivocamos.Un estudio de la UCL de hace un par de años, descubrió que la idea de los “21 días” no es mas que un mito… […]
-
7
Subconscious: What’s it All About, Plus 4 Ways to Influence Yours | Life's Books wrote on 9 November 2015:
[…] don’t know if you’ve heard that it takes 21 days for a behavior to become a habit. It seems that this is false, as on average, it takes around 66 days for that to happen. However, that number is still pretty […]
-
8
How to Start Clean Eating in 6 Easy Steps wrote on 9 November 2015:
[…] has often been said that new habits can be formed in just 21 days, but research has exposed some flaws in this thinking. Making meaningful life changes can often take several months or more. “People […]
-
9
How to Start Clean Eating in 7 Easy Steps wrote on 9 November 2015:
[…] has mostly been pronounced that new habits can be formed in usually 21 days, though investigate has exposed some flaws in this thinking. Making suggestive life changes can mostly take several months or more. “People […]
-
10
Doubting Thomas | Break your New Year’s Resolutions now and get it over with – Doubting Thomas wrote on 2 December 2015:
[…] University College in London put paid to the myth that it takes 21 days to successfully acquire a new behaviour (British […]
-
11
4 Science-Based Strategies to Hack Your Next Power Habit wrote on 8 December 2015:
[…] at University College London’s Health Behavior Research Center. These researchers traced the reference back to the 1960 bestseller Psycho-Cybernetics, written by American plastic surgeon […]
-
12
4 Science-Based Strategies to Hack Your Next Power Habit | Bradley's World wrote on 8 December 2015:
[…] psychologists at University College London’s Health Behavior Research Center. These researchers traced the reference back to the 1960 bestseller Psycho-Cybernetics, written by American plastic surgeon […]
-
13
50 Golden Rules for Forming Healthy Habits wrote on 10 December 2015:
[…] You may feel like that habit is solidified after a couple of weeks, and it may well be – but the data suggests otherwise. […]
-
14
Arbitrary Year’s Resolutions | A Blog wrote on 1 January 2016:
[…] intense, context-dependent repetition to form. In common mythology, habits take 21 days to develop; according to University College London, that number is closer to 66. Irrespective of the precise number of days after which one can expect to have created a new […]
-
15
A New Year, A New… Excuse? – AM Health wrote on 5 January 2016:
[…] old habits can be difficult to break. This article suggests that if you can sustain a behavior for an average of 66 days, then the behavior will supersede the previous habit and become habitual making it significantly […]
- 16
- 17
- 18
- 19
-
20
The 6 Best Ways to Achieve Your Goals – Inspired Forward wrote on 18 November 2018:
[…] Historically, we’ve been told that it takes 21 days to create or establish a habit. According to recent research, that number is way off! […]
- 21
- 22
-
23
21 – Arete Academy wrote on 22 January 2019:
[…] surgeon theorist) tells us that it takes 21 days to form a new habit.Other theorists tell us that this is a myth and that it actually takes much […]
-
24
Assisted living wrote on 7 March 2021:
Great to come accross here, the article is worth reading and suits for Assisted living
- 25
-
26
Isha wrote on 10 March 2022:
App development company in Delhi: We have the Top iPhone Android app developers team, offering custom mobile app development Services.
-
27
Wilson Fox wrote on 13 July 2022:
I suffered from what they called peripheral artery disease (PAD). I have been suffering for years, Me and my wife searched for a medical cure, and then we came across a testimony of a man who suffered the same and was cured by Dr Chief Lucky. So my wife and I contacted Dr Chief Lucky via an email and thank God he replied. I explained what was wrong and he sent me herbal medicines that helped heal me completely. I am happy to say that herbal medicine is the ultimate and Dr Chief Lucky I am grateful. You can contact him on his email: chiefdrlucky@gmail.com or whatsapp: +2348132777335, Dr Chief Lucky said that he also specializes in the following diseases: LUPUS, ALS, CANCER, HPV, HERPES, DIABETES, COPD, HEPATITIS B, HIV AIDS, And more.
-
28
justin wrote on 1 August 2022:
I really like the content you shared. I will definitely follow the 21 days habit myth and post you the update.
- 29
- 30
- 31
-
32
Parvati and sons wrote on 3 September 2022:
Parvati and sons is a Uttarakhand-based IT Company. Parvati and sons was established in 2018 for startups, small businesses, and businesses to automate business works. Holding with this vision we had done so many projects in different cities in India. Our top services are website development, e-commerce website development, android, and IOS app development. We have a dedicated team that gives 100% to deliver the most satisfying work experience to our clients.
https://www.parvatiandsons.in/ -
33
Vijay wrote on 7 September 2022:
Great Blog! Habit formation depends on a person’s nature. How quickly he can grasp a habit But sometimes we can take the help of modern technology to improve our habits. Many mobile apps are also available in the play store from where we can download the app and it helps in our daily lifestyle. We also develop many types of Mobile App including fitness and daily lifestyle related. You can check on our blog and assess your requirements.
- 34
- 35
-
36
Cotttech Solution wrote on 7 November 2022:
We are the leading provider of corrugation services in the industry. That’s because we offer everything you need — from installation and commissioning, to break down and maintenance services, to the enhancement of machine productivity and quality. With our expertise, you can be sure that your machinery is always running at optimal levels.
https://corrtechsolutions.com/blog/details/best-corrugation-service-providers-in-uttarakhand/ -
37
Task Hours wrote on 2 December 2022:
Regarding habit formation, we must include proper time management on this article. Our software Task Hours automates time tracking and attendance of your employees so you can track the productivity of your business in real-time. Task Hours is packed with many advance features of time management
. You can visit us for more.
[…] En University College London, Busting the 21 days habit formation myth, […]