X Close

BRITS cell therapy project planning and valuation tool

Home

Menu

Case study 1: Process change case study

By zceie01, on 1 June 2014

Data on manufacturing costs were collected by Dr Sally Hassan with help of LONZA. Dr Suzy Farid also contributed to the development of this case study. Some data on manufacturing costs in this case study are blacked out subject to peer review and publication.

The BRITS tool can provide guidance to stakeholders in cell therapy projects in the development of manufacturing strategies. Managers have at their disposal options to use a range of manufacturing technologies along the development pathways. The BRITS tool will provide guidance for managers:

  • In assessing how investments and pay-offs associated with different manufacturing technologies affect the firm’s cash flows.
  • In evaluating how switches between different technologies along the development pathway affect these cash flows.
  • In deciding on optimal manufacturing strategies for the commercialisation of a specific project.
Different scenarios for manufacturing strategies

We use the case study of company X, which is developing a new allogeneic cell therapy product. The company has completed preclinical studies and has regulatory approval to proceed with a phase I/IIa study to assess the therapy’s safety and to collect preliminary data on the therapy’s efficacy. As they are planning the project’s development trajectory all the way through FDA approval, managers are weighing several options. Specifically, managers are considering whether to set up manufacturing using more traditional, and cheaper planar cell expansion processes or whether to opt for more advanced, and more expensive 3-D single use cell expansion processes. While requiring a higher upfront investment, these 3-D single use cell expansion processes will allow the company significantly reduce post-commercialisation per unit manufacturing costs.

Apart from considering whether to use either planar or MC-SUB technology all the way along the development trajectory (scenario’s A+E), managers consider various scenarios that involve switching from planar to MC-SUB technology as clinical trials progress and uncertainty about market approval is reduced. Figure 1 highlights these various scenarios.

Figure 1: Scenarios for different manufacturing strategies

1

Business planning for the cell therapy company X is developing builds on a number of assumptions that are used as input for the tool.

Figure 2.1: Project assumptions that are fixed across scenarios (clinical trials)

2.1


 
 
 
 
 
Figure 2.2: Project assumptions that are fixed across scenarios (staffing)

2.2

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Figure 2.3: Project assumptions that are fixed across scenarios (other)

2.3

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

In addition, managers have obtained input from a contract manufacturer about the manufacturing costs associated with different scenarios (see figure 3).

Figure 3: Project assumptions that vary across scenarios

3

Finally, managers expect clinical trials 1, to take 1 year to complete, clinical trials 2, 2 years to complete, and clinical trials 3, 3 years to complete. Moreover, contract manufacturers warn managers that changing manufacturing processes at a specific stage of the development process requires managers to factor in a one-year delay in the duration of the clinical trials for that stage, and will require the company to conduct a bridging study involving fifteen subjects to satisfy regulators.

Valuation of different scenarios for manufacturing strategies

Using the BRITS tool, users are able to assess the NPV for the different scenarios. Assuming that the company will be able to charge $10k for its product post-commercialisation, the tool provides the following valuations (see figure 4).

Figure 4: Valuation of different scenarios assuming therapy can be commercialised at a price of US$ 10k

4

Figure 4 suggests that the highest valuation of the project is realised if managers select scenario A as the basis for the company’s manufacturing strategy, and stick to the more traditional planar technology throughout the commercialisation process. Thus, given the assumptions underlying the tool’s calculations, benefits in terms of lower costs of goods post-commercialisation of the new MS-SUB technology do not weigh up against the increased upfront investments for this technology.

The assumption that the company will be able to sell its product at a price of $10k means that it will enjoy a significant gross profit margin. Under scenario A, the company would enjoy a gross profit margin of $7,317/$10,000 = 73%, and

under scenarios B, C, D, E, the company would enjoy a margin of $8,500/$10,000 = 85%.

Assessing different scenarios for manufacturing strategies under different conditions

Managers  For example, managers often overestimate the willingness to pay for novel cell therapies and the profit margins their firms are able to sustain in the market. The BRITS tool is useful in assessing how reductions in gross profit margins firms are projected to realise, affect trade-offs managers face.

Figure 5 highlights how reductions in the price of the cell therapy alter valuations of the different manufacturing scenarios. As the price the firm charges for its cell therapy product decreases, scenario A falls down the ranking of the scenarios with the highest valuation. With a reduction of the price of the cell therapy product by half, it becomes more attractive to switch to MC-SUB manufacturing technology for phase 3 (scenario B), or phase 2 clinical trials (scenario C), than to stick to planar technology throughout (scenario A).

Figure 5: NPVs of manufacturing scenarios at different price points of cell therapy

5

 

31 Responses to “Case study 1: Process change case study”

  • 1
    Anirudh Singh wrote on 15 February 2022:

    Nice content, keep sharing with us. Credit Cards

  • 2
  • 3
    imperio wrote on 7 March 2022:

    Hey, thanks for sharing a very helpful and informative blog.

  • 4
    imperio wrote on 7 March 2022:

    Hey, thanks for sharing a very helpful and informative blog.
    federal bank

  • 5
    Himanshi wrote on 17 June 2022:

    Detailed and informative.

  • 6
    Aspire Bedding wrote on 12 May 2023:

    Get the best comforter sets price in Pakistan at Aspire Bedding. Find high-quality bedding at an affordable rate for a comfortable sleep experience.

  • 7
    Mannat Clothing wrote on 12 May 2023:

    Celebrate Eid in style with Mannat Clothing’s exquisite collection of Eid dresses for girls, featuring intricate details and stunning designs that are sure to turn heads.

  • 8
    Panache Apparel wrote on 12 May 2023:

    Panache Apparel is a popular online clothing store in Pakistan and ladies’ clothes brand. They provide women with various stylish and trendy clothes, from casual to formal clothes. Panache Apparel is one of the top online clothing stores in the country; Panache Apparel has established a reputation for offering premium goods at competitive prices. They are known for paying close attention to every detail, providing excellent customer service, and timely delivery. Panache Apparel is a ladies clothes shop for fashion-conscious women in Pakistan.

  • 9
    Qhaaf Bedding wrote on 13 May 2023:

    Qhaaf Bedding is a renowned online brand in Pakistan, offering an exquisite range of bridal bed sheets and bridal bed sheet sets at competitive prices. With an extensive collection that caters to the diverse tastes of Pakistani brides, Qhaaf Bedding ensures quality and elegance while providing the best value for your investment in bridal bed sheets in Pakistan.

  • 10
    chris jack wrote on 22 July 2023:

    Students may face difficulties with assignment help online due to various factors. Firstly, some individuals might struggle with understanding the specific requirements of their assignments, leading them to seek external guidance. While seeking assistance is beneficial, students should ensure they actively engage in learning to avoid dependency. Secondly, the vast number of online assignment help services can be overwhelming, making it hard for students to choose the most reliable and suitable option. Consequently, they may end up with subpar services that do not meet their expectations. Additionally, financial constraints could limit access to premium services, forcing students to opt for cheaper alternatives that may compromise the quality of assistance received. To overcome these challenges, students should develop effective study habits, research reputable service providers, and manage their time efficiently.

  • 11
    bebogra wrote on 14 August 2023:

    Whether you enjoy the thrill of defending against hordes of zombies, balloons, or other fantastical creatures, Tower Defense games provide a satisfying mix of strategy, action, and problem-solving.

  • 12
    Haim wrote on 5 October 2023:

    Remember those times when exams felt overwhelming? With our take my online test for me service, you can rediscover the confidence of years past. Supported by our seasoned experts, you can reignite your passion for learning and grasp the grades you’ve always yearned for. Let’s bring back those golden days of academic triumph.

  • 13
    johnalx wrote on 6 October 2023:

    This case study explores various manufacturing strategies for a cell therapy company, highlighting the importance of financial considerations and technology choices in different scenarios. Do you want a sport management thesis topics and ideas in the UK. I am here to assist you.

  • 14
    Anabella Jack wrote on 16 October 2023:

    Great case study on process change! It’s impressive how you’ve successfully implemented these improvements. Could you please share more about the methodology you used in this study? It would help me write a research question on process change for my own project. Thanks for the valuable insights!

  • 15
    Pak Print Wishes wrote on 20 October 2023:

    Pak Print Wishes an Best Online Printing Company truly stands out with its unique and creative printing and packaging solutions. They’re your one-stop destination for turning printing needs into exceptional, eye-catching results!

  • 16
    Pakprintwishes wrote on 23 October 2023:

    Make every gift special with our custom ring packaging. Crafted to perfection, our boxes add an extra layer of charm to those cherished moments.

  • 17
    brad oliver wrote on 23 October 2023:

    Enhance your creativity with our special Markers and highlighters. This flexible tool lets you express your inner artist and improve what you do. Our markers and highlighters are ideal for illustrators and builders.

  • 18
    yati singhal wrote on 8 November 2023:

    Case studies on process changes are like roadmaps to improvement! It’s great to learn from real examples of how change can lead to better results. #ContinuousImprovement

    twitch ad block

  • 19
    christinejohn wrote on 24 November 2023:

    The data on manufacturing costs presented in this case study offers a valuable glimpse into the intricacies of production economics. Analyzing these figures could undoubtedly yield crucial insights for optimizing efficiency. On a related note, I’m currently in search of a professional coursework writing service to enhance my understanding of such complex subjects.

  • 20
    Kaabir Singh wrote on 30 November 2023:

    24*7 Mahipalpur Escort to you with all warm a laugh you do choice to have romance and love in life at best prices to decorate all hidden and sexual person to give all proper amount of meal with Mahipalpur Escorts Girls clubs with Female and Modeling and Independent Escorts Mahipalpur on order.

  • 21
    Jonathan Naylor wrote on 18 December 2023:

    It was really difficult for me to understand the process of case study writing. However, the process that you have shared will prove to be a great case study help as it involves all steps from writing to analysing on the basis of different scenarios for manufacturing strategies. The use of figures also makes it more trustworthy.

  • 22
    Mary Taylor wrote on 18 December 2023:

    The future of content moderation is here, and this ai content detector punctuation and grammar checker is leading the way! It’s incredible how technology has evolved to help us filter and moderate content effectively, ensuring a safer and more responsible online environment. With the growing volume of digital content, the need for accurate and efficient content moderation has never been more critical. This tool not only detects inappropriate or harmful content but also adapts to new trends and threats, staying one step ahead. It’s a valuable addition to any platform or website, promoting a healthier online space.

  • 23
    Bolamd Thomas wrote on 18 December 2023:

    Gracias por otro gran post. ¿Dónde más podría alguien obtener esa información escrita de manera tan perfecta? Esto es realmente interesante, eres un blogger muy hábil. Me uní a tu feed y espero con ansias más de tus excelentes publicaciones. ¡Además, he compartido tu sitio en mis redes sociales!
    Acompañantes Merlo

  • 24
    Lorenza Smith wrote on 15 January 2024:

    Shop bb belt, BB Hoodies, BB T Shirts and BB Jewelry etc from BB Simon Official Online Website Premium Quality Worldwide Shipping

  • 25
    Hari Johnli wrote on 17 January 2024:

    Shop on cloud shoes for Men and Women Latest designs at 30 Sale Worldwide Fast Shipping On Cloud Shoes Official Website

  • 26
    Sarah Mcneil wrote on 24 January 2024:

    We are the center for Dissertation Writers In UK, offering students the quickest support possible. Our clients don’t have to worry about missing their thesis deadlines. We provide the work on schedule so that students can submit their theses with assurance. Speak with us and maintain your self-assurance.

  • 27
    Mary Creasman wrote on 25 January 2024:

    We are the leaders of the academic writing sector. There’s no reason to panic if you don’t know what academic writing is. You can obtain the assistance you require without going over budget thanks to the
    Best Dissertation Writing Services Near Me speed, dependability, and affordability. To discover more about our offerings and how we can support you in achieving your academic objectives, get in touch with us right now.

  • 28
    David Sharonfrankklin wrote on 17 February 2024:

    The market continues to evolve, with new devices and flavors constantly emerging. One of the Smart key attractions of electric smoke vapes is the wide range of flavors available. Users can choose from traditional tobacco, menthol, fruit, dessert, and many other flavors.

  • 29
    sfaa wrote on 19 February 2024:

    If you like to watch sex movies, you are welcome to our site. amateur porns

  • 30
    Joshua Jasmine wrote on 20 February 2024:

    Superb post. I am sure that this content will be valuable Brisbane escort services for all of us. Thanks for sharing such an awesome post.

  • 31
    mitchell wrote on 20 February 2024:

    Complete levels to collect secret coins, used to unlock new icons, trails, and even custom colors for your cube in geometry dash lite

Leave a Reply